[special-K]

I like that siding way better than the lap siding.But,it`s actually the same thing.In the proper application it looks better.As far as being vinyl,it`s better than lap because of the verticle breaks both in visual and structural.This was as cheap as you can go with a shingle look.It`s a lighter gauge,doesn`t come varigated (shaded like woodgrain),and they don`t offer a "cornerless" piece (actually looks like no corner) where the shingles run around the corner with no board,like the original.It would have been nicer to have "jammed" & "cased" the openings on the porch.I would have used 1 x 12 on the sides and trimmed in 5/4 x 4 (like windows),including arches.
The Hardy Plank is catching on,but around here many just stop listening when you say "paint".Even pre-finish doesn`t matter to some.It`s used where you wouldn`t expect to see vinyl and being offered in place of vinyl on some tract housing.I like it.We`ll see how father time treats it.Masonite turned out no good around here.Cement fiber took over that market,first.It`s replacing cedar on many homes,too.