I'm happy to say that the folks at Discount Tire stepped up and took care of things, without any hassle at all. They genuinely felt worse about it than I did and really went the extra mile to make sure I was happy, so a big tip of the hat to those guys. I'll definitely use them again.
Here's a sneak peak of how the wheels look on the car. It's boxed in so I can't get any good shots of the side of the car. Keep in mind the car is up on stands all corners until I get the front end work done and the air system set up.