Ryan I'm sure we all have these kind of stories.
Well I just came back from installing the new starter with negative results. I pulled it back out and bench tested them both and they both seem to work fine. I put Kens new one back in just in time before it started raining. I couldn't get it to crank so I left it sitting in the parking lot at the office. The bad thing is that is suppose to rain pretty heavy here for the next few days. I guess when the rain quits I will start to dig back into it. Stay tuned everyone.