Thinking about your thread Doc, I really wanted these bumper nuts badly. I have eight already zinc plated. My rear step bumper didn't have them, but a sport bumper does, which I'm using. At any rate, I had three extra for some reason, & stole another six off my C20. That truck is pretty well rusty, so the nuts took some doing.
I don't like soaking parts in vinegar too long or often. These took three vinegar baths as is, two with a pinch of Must For Rust too. You can help the process with WD-40 baths, which I did, twice
, I really wanted these nuts. WD-40 loosens up the rust (black) some, that and a scrub pad works well.
First picture is what the nuts looked like after the first vinegar bath, brushing and an oil bath. If it's black it's "still rust" and HARD. That black doesn't bode well for anything short of paint.
Second picture is of them finished, but a little sanding in places due. One nut is pretty bad, but I don't need it.
Third pic is what they'll look like, though the plated nuts were in much better condition from start.