[weq92f]

.
My vote is VA, however I've no experience with the other complete replacement brands.

As for the controller options...The VA interface to the factory controller doesn't use the fan switch and so you end up with some awkward controls but they do work.

VA's 4 knob controller is what I'm running and all 4 knobs are functional, they light up nice and they look and feel solid.

VA includes what they call "cable converters" which convert your factory controller over to control the VA unit ( see above ).

I like the look of the factory controller better than the VA...but don't dig the funky controls.

Hth,

-klb