[Gregski]

here is a side by side comparison of the first two Challengers to each other in natural light - outdoors

the winner (in my opinion and you form your own please) RUST-OLEUM Matte from Home Depot on the buttom (passenger side inner fender)

and the too shinny RUST-OLEUM Semi Gloss from LOWE'S on the top (driver side inner fender)

keep in mind the Champion thus far is actually the KRYLON Semi Flat (see if keeping that straight doesn't drive you crazy - ha ha)