AM I wrong in being disappointed?

[morepwr]

I would be more likely to give a pass to the kick panel areas if the carpet had been glued down like it appears to have been and the guy you bought it from never pulled it back to look. But if the carpet was already pulled off then it was a lie as it obviously needs some work done. I would not give a pass to the fender that has obviously been covered in Bondo over rust though.